Press release: Principles and practice – early partnership in cohesion policy 2014–2020
Publications
Press release: Principles and practice – early partnership in cohesion policy 2014–2020
As EU Member States negotiate the budget for the next seven years, NGOs in Central and Eastern Europe are stressing that the purposes for which the money is spent matter. Making EU cohesion-policy funding serve sustainable development requires a broad range of considerations. Decision-makers and all stakeholders must work closely together from the earliest stages of programming. New research, however, shows that broad agreement on the need for partnership does not prevent practice from varying between countries.
Budapest, Warsaw, Prague, Târgu Mureș, Varna, Bratislava and Riga, 29 November 2012
The international NGO network SFteam for a Sustainable Future today published its latest research (1) on how social partners and civil-society organisations participate in planning the use of 2014–2020 cohesion-policy funds in seven EU Member States: Bulgaria, Latvia, Poland, the Czech Republic, Romania, Slovakia and Hungary.
In early 2012, SFteam developed a checklist of measures needed for meaningful partnership in cohesion-policy programming and later stages of the policy cycle (2). Since then, we have advocated these steps with NGOs and public officials. The study, supported financially by the International Visegrad Fund (IVF), also summarises stakeholders’ views on these measures.
“The NGOs and public officials interviewed generally agree with these principles, and governments tend to regard civil society as an indispensable partner in programming. How the principles are put into practice, however, differs considerably between the countries studied,” said Teodóra Dönsz-Kovács, SFteam deputy coordinator and programme manager at MTVSZ.
“Access to information on cohesion-policy planning varies widely. Up-to-date information is available in some countries, such as Bulgaria and Latvia, while in others—such as Hungary—information is almost entirely absent. Governments often struggle to accommodate the diversity of civil society in the planning process, as in Slovakia and the Czech Republic. Romania and Bulgaria also face the problem of failing to involve legitimate and broadly recognised civil-society representatives. Elsewhere, the role of NGO working groups and partnership forums is unclear, as in Latvia, or consultation periods are too short, as in Poland and Slovakia. All of this hinders meaningful consultation,” said Zoltán Hajdu, one of the researchers.
Contact
Focus Eco Center, SFteam’s partner in Romania
Dr Zoltán Hajdu, General Coordinator
Phone: 0744 774897
Email: focuseco@rdslink.ro
Notes
- Principles and Practice: Early Partnership in Cohesion Policy 2014–2020, www.focuseco.ro.
- Sixteen Principles for Successful Partnership in the Use of EU Funds, May 2012, sfteam.eu.
- Annex: key findings by country.
Bulgaria
It is unclear why the government created a new system for selecting NGOs to take part in programming when an effective NGO-led system, recognised by several ministries, already exists. It is also unclear why the government would favour a less experienced or less recognised applicant over a more competent organisation.
Czech Republic
The government expects civil society to nominate a single organisation for consultation, as trade unions do. Czech civil society consists of several thematic and regional networks, none of which represents most NGOs in the country. The government appears unwilling to accept this reality and seeks to involve civil society through its Government Council for NGOs, even though the Council does not include representatives chosen by consensus among Czech NGOs. Limiting civil-society participation to this Council is unacceptable.
Poland
The government deserves credit for holding a public consultation on the draft cohesion-policy regulations in late 2011. However, the consultation lasted only two weeks, including the Christmas and New Year period. There are also no clear, binding rules for drafting key documents that would ensure the participation of social partners and NGOs.
Latvia
The government regularly informs the public about EU-fund planning and implementation through a well-known website and has held public consultations on cohesion-policy rules. NGO participation has not been restricted so far. Several initiatives are under way, including a Finance Ministry proposal for a shadow monitoring committee open to any interested organisation and a cooperation memorandum between the government and 250 NGOs. These could provide effective consultation forums, but their role in programming remains unclear.
Hungary
Programming is substantially delayed and public information is difficult to obtain. There are indications that the government does not intend to involve civil society or the wider public. The composition of the National Development Government Committee is also a serious concern. It has primary responsibility for cohesion-policy planning, yet its core membership excludes representatives of two ministries whose work is significantly affected: the Ministry of Human Recommended resources and the Ministry of Rural Development, which is also responsible for environmental protection.
Romania
To ensure consistent application of the partnership principle, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs issued a memorandum in June 2012, which regional development agencies also implemented at regional level. NGOs generally report that they can access information about the planning process. Although civil-society representatives take part in regional and thematic working groups, ministries have not clearly defined the criteria for selecting potential registered partners. The government may also fail to provide an official response to a registered partner for as long as six months.
Slovakia
Little public information is available about cohesion-policy preparations, and it is often accessible only on request. Several official forums allow participation in programming, including the Partnership for Cohesion Policy working group and the Government Committee for the Future of the Partnership Agreement. The government nevertheless appears to prefer ad hoc cooperation with civil society and is unwilling to adopt written partnership rules. NGOs may therefore have only a limited role in upcoming consultations. It is welcome that the government commissioner for civil society intends to represent NGOs on the government committee, but this is indirect representation rather than direct partnership.
Updates
Focus Eco Center