The DNSH Principle: Do No Significant Harm
Climate change
The DNSH Principle: Do No Significant Harm
Assessing the environmental impact of a project is complex and often debated. Scientific evidence shows that human activity has a substantial effect on ecological systems and can have serious consequences for human civilisation.
Combined impacts on biodiversity, climate, water and air quality can be irreversible, and may be especially severe for large infrastructure investments. Recent experience shows that the effects of such projects may become visible only over time—often too late, when restoring conditions is impossible or prohibitively expensive.
When launching the European Green Deal and the Recovery and Resilience Facility, implemented in Romania through its National Recovery and Resilience Plan (PNRR), the European Commission introduced the DNSH principle to prevent funding for projects with significant negative environmental impacts. Romania received €29.2 billion to support the transition to a climate-friendly economy. This is an exceptional opportunity to develop projects that support a sustainable economy which does not harm the environment, including after 2026, when EU funding is set to fall sharply.
Projects intended to develop the economy may fund activities that damage the environment. Correct application of the DNSH principle helps prevent this.
What does “do no significant harm” mean?
Under the Regulation establishing the Recovery and Resilience Facility, DNSH must be interpreted in line with Article 17 of the Taxonomy Regulation. That article defines significant harm in relation to six environmental objectives:
- An activity causes significant harm to climate-change mitigation if it leads to significant greenhouse-gas emissions.
- An activity causes significant harm to climate-change adaptation if it increases the adverse effects of current or expected future climate on the activity itself, people, nature or assets.
- An activity causes significant harm to the sustainable use and protection of water and marine resources if it damages the good status or ecological potential of water bodies, including surface water and groundwater, or the good environmental status of marine waters.
- An activity causes significant harm to the circular economy, including waste prevention and recycling, if it leads to a significant loss of efficiency in using materials or natural resources, a significant increase in waste generation, incineration or disposal, or significant, lasting environmental damage from long-term waste disposal.
- An activity causes significant harm to pollution prevention and control if it significantly increases emissions of pollutants into air, water or land.
- An economic activity causes significant harm to the protection and restoration of biodiversity and ecosystems if it significantly damages the good condition and resilience of ecosystems or the conservation status of habitats and species, including those of EU interest.
How does DNSH apply to the Recovery and Resilience Facility?
Every measure must be assessed under DNSH, although a simplified assessment may be used in certain cases. Member States must submit a DNSH assessment for every measure in their recovery and resilience plans. No measure in a plan may significantly harm environmental objectives; the Commission cannot give a positive assessment to a plan if even one measure fails to comply.
Member States must therefore assess each measure individually. The assessment applies to individual measures, not to the plan as a whole or to its components. This covers measures that directly support the green transition as well as all other measures in the plan. Both reforms and investments must be assessed.
DNSH therefore applies to reforms as well as investments. Reforms in sectors such as industry, transport and energy may contribute significantly to the green transition, but depending on their design they may also cause significant harm to several environmental objectives. Reforms in areas such as education and training, public administration, arts and culture are likely to pose only limited environmental risks while still contributing significantly to the green transition.
Simplified assessment may be used for some measures
Every measure requires a DNSH assessment, but a simplified approach may be used when a measure is expected to have no or only an insignificant effect on one or more of the six environmental objectives. A measure may deliberately have only a limited effect on certain objectives. In that case, the Member State may briefly justify its conclusion for those objectives and focus the substantive assessment on objectives that could be significantly affected.
For example, a labour-market reform to improve general social protection for self-employed people is expected to have no or only an insignificant effect on the six environmental objectives; a brief justification may be sufficient for each. Similarly, for some straightforward energy-efficiency measures—such as replacing old windows with energy-efficient ones—a short explanation may demonstrate compliance with DNSH for climate-change mitigation.
This simplified method is unlikely to apply to investments and reforms that pose greater risks to one or more environmental objectives, for example in energy, transport, waste management and industry.
Under the Recovery and Resilience Facility’s climate-tracking methodology, a measure may be considered DNSH-compliant for an environmental objective if it is recorded as making a 100% contribution to that objective. If a measure is recorded as fully supporting climate-change mitigation or adaptation, DNSH is considered fulfilled for that objective. The same applies when a measure makes a 100% contribution to another environmental objective: water and marine resources, the circular economy, pollution prevention, or biodiversity and ecosystems.
In every case, Member States must identify and justify which of the Taxonomy Regulation’s six environmental objectives a measure supports. They must also demonstrate that the measure does not significantly harm the other environmental objectives.
Further information: European Commission guidance on applying DNSH. The Central Regional Development Agency also provides useful information.
Updates
Focus Eco Center